Elite Consulting are UK stress analysis consultants providing Pro/Engineer and Pro/Mechanica training courses, software consultancy and support.

Home
Up

 

     

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Spot Weld Tips & Tricks in Pro/MECHANICA® Structure

Rod Giles BSc.,MSc.,NRA

CEP Functional Simulation


Spot welds are a great way to connect two or more parts together in Pro/Mechanica.They combine beams and links to give the correct type of connection that simulates any discrete connection that is used in engineering. So they can be used to model not only spot-welds but also rivets, pins screws and bolts.

Spot-welds work by creating a beam that is perpendicular to the surfaces that you want to join. For this reason the surfaces have to be reasonably parallel where you want to join them (within 5 degrees). It's perfectly possible to spot-weld two cylindrical surfaces together. The beam is connected to the two surfaces by a special link, or multi-point constraint, that rigidises the surface at the diameter of the spot-weld. This means that moments are correctly transferred to the surfaces.

Spot-welds can be created on parts that are solid or shells or both. Also bear in mind that the point that you use to specify the spot-weld location does not have to be on either of the two surfaces that you pick, merely that Mechanica must be able to project this point onto the surface. If the part has a shell definition then at run time the beam ends are projected to the mid-surface, together with the links.

There are times when Mechanica won't create a spot weld or creates one in the wrong place. Be sure to check that you picked the correct surfaces, always use query-select. If Mechanica still doesn't create the spot-weld correctly, try selecting a different pair of surfaces if the parts are shell-paired. Mechanica will not create spot-weld if there is zero distance between the surfaces. In this case make sure to select the two opposing surfaces to make sure that the is a gap between them.

Although it's pretty straightforward to join two parts together, when you want to join three or more things can get a bit tricky. Mechanica will not create co-axial spot welds if the one of the surfaces that is selected is the same as was used for a previous spot-weld. So if you have three parts to join, A,B & C, then follow this procedure:
bulletJoin outer surface A to nearest surface of B.
bulletJoin Outer surface of C to nearest surface of B.
bulletJoin inner surface of A to inner surface of C.

Spot Weld - 3 Plates

This works for solid and shell models. If you have more parts to join then this technique can be used if the number of parts is odd. If the number of parts are even then you run out of surfaces to pick. The only option is to create a slightly offset spot weld, as shown below:
Spot Weld - 4 Plates
In Mechanica 2000i2 there's also a slight problem with co-axial spot-welds: the analysis will run properly, but it finishes with a fatal error! This is OK if you are interested in just looking at results, but if you want to use the analysis for something else, like using the results of a modal analysis for a dynamic analysis, then it won't work! The only recourse is to offset the spot-welds.

Home Up Contact Links

Stress Analysis Consultants  Mechanical Engineering Consultancy  Pro/Engineer Wildfire  Pro/Mechanica  Pro/Engineer Training  CETol Software  Graficalc Software  Design Automation   Design Optimisation  FMEA  New Product Development  PD-Trak NPD Software  CFD Analysis  Tolerance Analysis

Questions or comments about this web site should be addressed to .
Copyright © 1998 - 2008 Elite Consulting Ltd. Registered in England & Wales No. 2823712 . Last modified: April 05, 2008

Pro/ENGINEER, MECHANICA, Wildfire, Windchill & Behavioural Modelling are trademarks or registered trademarks of Parametric Technology Corporation or its subsidiaries in the U.S. and in other countries. CETol is a trademark of Sigmetrix LLC. PD-Trak is a trademark of PD-Trak Solutions. GrafiCalc & ToleranceCalc are trademarks of Geomate Company. Stage-Gate is a registered trademark of Product Development Institutte Inc.

Some text and images on this web site have been supplied by kind permission of Sigmetrix, Geomate & PD-Trak.